Because you got far too many points for the game before it?
749 Ruufio € 153811212 17 0 Yes 2012-03-14 13:00:21
748 Ruufio € 154430128 18 37 Yes 2012-03-13 20:30:05
Something is buggered up there. You shouldn't get 37 points for an 18 year finish - that's horrible.
Edit: Maybe some of this is related to the fact that the servers are reporting -years on running time. For instance, #2 is at 2001 right now but the reported start date is 2010 (when it's usually 1975, IIRC).
BTPro servers are the only ones with -years and wonky start dates on the OpenTTD server list.